The dessert you promised to bring

Where to Order Thanksgiving Pies in Texas, 2026

Dinner is handled. Dessert is your job. Here is where to start in Dallas–Fort Worth, Houston, Austin and San Antonio—with whole-pie prices, order cutoffs and the pickup details worth reading before you pay.

By Texas Restaurant Menus · Source checks and page update: · Thanksgiving: Thursday, November 26

Where can you buy Thanksgiving pies in Texas?

For published whole-pie prices, start with Village Baking Co. in Dallas, Ms. Myrtle’s in Houston or Bakery Lorraine’s San Antonio and Austin pickup choices. For a walk-in purchase during Thanksgiving week, Flying Saucer has a different model: no reservations or holds. A menu listing is not a promise that a flavor or slot is still available.

Compare the same purchase

Thanksgiving pie prices and deadlines at a glance

These examples are whole pies, not slices. Amounts exclude tax and delivery unless the bakery says otherwise. Coverage is a selected shortlist in four metropolitan areas, not every Texas city or bakery.

Published examples checked November 19 · see each profile for exceptions and source links
Bakery / areaExample pricePublished order cutoffCollection arrangement
Village Baking Co.Dallas · choose a café$29.95 pumpkinNov 23Nov 20–25; café selection
SusieCakes · Preston CenterDallas · 6100 Luther Lane$39.99 pumpkinNov 24, 5 p.m.Nov 25; preorder only
PistachéDFW · Richardson, Arlington or Murphy pickup$45 pumpkinNov 24Nov 25–26; partner café or delivery
Ms. Myrtle’s BakeryHouston · 2020 Emancipation Avenue$25 pumpkinNov 19Nov 24–25; assigned time
The Blind GoatHouston · Spring Branch$42 appleNot statedNov 16–25 evenings; frozen pie
Flying Saucer Pie CompanyHouston · 436 W Crosstimbers StreetAsk for current pricesWalk-in onlyNov 23–25; no holds
Sweet Treets BakeryAustin · Oak Hill / South AustinCheck the order menuNov 21; confirm “midnight”Nov 25, 9 a.m.–6:30 p.m.
Bakery LorraineSan Antonio + Austin · select a holiday pickup branch$30 pumpkinNov 21Nov 24–25; branch-specific hours

If a bakery gives a cutoff date without a time, do not assume you can order until 11:59 p.m. A published ordering period can also close early when production fills.

Find your dessert stop

A Thanksgiving pie shortlist, city by city

Pumpkin and pecan are easy to compare by name. The less obvious differences are whether you are buying a baked pie, a frozen pie, a tray of pastries or an unreserved place in a queue.

Eight bakery options. All details and source links are readable without JavaScript.

Dallas & the DFW area

Three different ordering arrangements

Published cutoff: Monday, November 23; no closing hour stated.

Dallas · choose a café

Village Baking Co.

$29.95 pumpkin

Pumpkin $29.95; bourbon maple pecan $39.95; chocolate bourbon maple pecan $42.95. Apple galette $39.95.

Size / portions
Whole pie; bakery says the pumpkin and pecan pies serve eight.
Order by
Monday, November 23; no closing hour stated.
Collect
November 20–25, at least one day after ordering. Select your café and time.

A straightforward choice when you want a traditional pie and a published serving count. The galette is a different format, so do not assume its size or yield matches the round pies. Holiday ordering is separate from the normal café order-ahead menu.

The holiday page lists multiple Dallas cafés. The café on your confirmation is the collection point; normal opening hours are not a holiday pickup appointment.

Official menu and ordering details ↗

Published cutoff: Tuesday, November 24, 5 p.m. Central.

Dallas · 6100 Luther Lane

SusieCakes · Preston Center

$39.99 pumpkin

The retrieved PRC Dallas branch menu lists pumpkin at $39.99 and Southern pecan at $42.99. Apple crumble is listed at $45.99.

Size / portions
9-inch pumpkin and pecan pies; no serving count used here.
Order by
Tuesday, November 24, 5 p.m. Central.
Collect
Wednesday, November 25 is preorder pickup only. Bakeries are listed closed November 26–27.

This is a branch-specific price check, not a chainwide quote. Search snippets showed a lower pumpkin amount than the retrieved menu, so use the selected store’s checkout total. Choose the baked apple pie if that is what you want: a separate take-and-bake version is also sold.

No walk-ins are advertised for November 25. A temporary online-ordering message is not enough to determine holiday stock; schedule the date or contact the branch.

Official menu and ordering details ↗

Published cutoff: Tuesday, November 24, or earlier if capacity fills; no closing hour stated.

DFW · Richardson, Arlington or Murphy pickup

Pistaché

$45 pumpkin

Baklava pumpkin pie: $45 for 8-inch or $68 for 10-inch. Apple pie baklava: $50 for 12 pieces or $75 for 21.

Size / portions
8-inch pumpkin serves 6–8; 10-inch serves 10–12.
Order by
Tuesday, November 24, or earlier if capacity fills; no closing hour stated.
Collect
November 25 or 26. DFW delivery is also advertised, with a distance-based fee at checkout.

The collection choices are partner cafés: Shibam in Richardson, Haraz in Arlington and Arwa in Murphy. None is described here as a Dallas-city bakery counter. Keep the pumpkin pie refrigerated; the apple baklava tray is a different dessert with its own care instructions.

The bakery lists wheat, dairy, eggs and tree nuts in its Thanksgiving desserts. Choose the café and date during ordering, and confirm the collection address on the receipt.

Official menu and ordering details ↗

Houston

Preorders, a frozen pie and a walk-in shop

Published cutoff: Thursday, November 19; no closing hour stated.

Houston · 2020 Emancipation Avenue

Ms. Myrtle’s Bakery

$25 pumpkin

Pumpkin, apple and sweet potato are $25 each. Original pecan is $30; sweet potato caramel pecan is $35.

Size / portions
9-inch deep-dish pies; no published pie serving count used here.
Order by
Thursday, November 19; no closing hour stated.
Collect
November 24 or 25. The bakery contacts each customer with a time and order number.

This is the earliest cutoff in our shortlist. If you are reading after November 19, ask whether an exception is possible instead of assuming the published menu is still orderable. The price is for the pie, not a dessert package or a dinner.

The holiday page directs customers to call 713-951-9211 or text 833-551-6757. Confirm that an order is accepted before making collection plans.

Official menu and ordering details ↗Call the bakery

Published cutoff: No final order cutoff stated on the seasonal page.

Houston · Spring Branch

The Blind Goat

$42 apple

Rubbish Apple Pie is $42. It is supplied frozen with baking instructions and fish-sauce caramel.

Size / portions
Seasonal page says serves eight. Diameter differs between page and form: confirm it.
Order by
No final order cutoff stated on the seasonal page.
Collect
November 16–25, 5–9 p.m., at 8145 Long Point Road.

This is the pie for a household that has oven time available. It is not a ready-to-slice dessert to collect on the way to dinner. The seasonal page describes a 10-inch pie while its linked form says 9-inch; we have not silently chosen one measurement.

The page and form confirm the $42 price and frozen format but do not print a season year in the visible ordering text. Verify the selected 2026 date before payment. Ask about the sauce ingredients if needed.

Official menu and ordering details ↗Linked order form and size details ↗

Walk-in only; no reservations

Houston · 436 W Crosstimbers Street

Flying Saucer Pie Company

Ask for current prices

Use the official pie menu for flavors. Do not treat an older photographed price board as a confirmed 2026 quote.

Size / portions
Whole pies; a usable current price list was not available in the reviewed text.
Order by
No Thanksgiving-week preorders, holds or reservations.
Collect
November 23–24: 7 a.m.–7 p.m. November 25: 7 a.m.–5 p.m.

This works differently from the preorder bakeries. Thanksgiving-week purchases are first come, first served. The shop warns that queues vary, so no waiting-time estimate is promised here. It is a walk-in possibility, not a guaranteed backup after another bakery sells out.

The current Thanksgiving FAQ lists closure November 26–30. Confirm freshness and storage for the flavor you buy, especially if collecting before Wednesday.

Official menu and ordering details ↗Thanksgiving collection FAQ ↗

Austin

South Austin pickup, plus the shared Lorraine entry below

Published cutoff: Saturday, November 21; the bakery uses “midnight.” Confirm its exact closing boundary.

Austin · Oak Hill / South Austin

Sweet Treets Bakery

Check the order menu

The 2026 announcement lists caramel pumpkin, bourbon pecan, brown butter apple and lemon meringue pies.

Size / portions
Confirm pie size, yield and price in the linked order menu.
Order by
Saturday, November 21; the bakery uses “midnight.” Confirm its exact closing boundary.
Collect
November 25, 9 a.m.–6:30 p.m., at 6705 US-290, Suite 601.

The bakery says there will be some extra items for walk-in purchase, but it does not guarantee which flavors or quantities. For a particular Thanksgiving pie, preorder. No late pickup is offered; uncollected orders are donated.

The linked Square product pages did not expose a dependable price in the reviewed text. We have left the amount unstated rather than borrowing a previous year’s price.

Official menu and ordering details ↗Call 512-892-2233

San Antonio + a North Austin option

One bakery, several collection choices

Published cutoff: Saturday, November 21; no closing hour stated.

San Antonio + Austin · select a holiday pickup branch

Bakery Lorraine

$30 pumpkin

Roasted pumpkin streusel is $30. Whiskey pecan, Dutch apple and several cream-pie options are $35 each.

Size / portions
Confirm the selected pie’s diameter and serving count.
Order by
Saturday, November 21; no closing hour stated.
Collect
November 24 or 25. The pumpkin product lists 9 a.m.–5 p.m.; Medical Center closes at 3 p.m.

The holiday selector includes Pearl, Medical Center and The Rim in San Antonio, Domain ATX in Austin, and additional collection choices. A café’s usual schedule is not the holiday pickup window. Select the date and branch together; stock can differ by combination.

The online shop includes generic unavailable-variant text. That alone does not establish that every pie is sold out. Check the actual product, date and branch selection.

Official menu and ordering details ↗Pumpkin price and pickup selector ↗

Before you use a flavor filter for dietary needs: it identifies a named flavor, not ingredients or allergy suitability. An apple dessert can contain nuts, and a caramel sauce can contain an ingredient you would not expect. Ask the bakery about the entire product, toppings and shared equipment.
Enough dessert, without a fridge full of leftovers

How many Thanksgiving pies should you buy?

Start with the people eating pie

Count the guests likely to want dessert, then ask what else is coming. Twelve people sharing pie, cake and cookies need a different order from twelve people with pie as the only dessert. A second flavor can be useful even when you do not need a second pie for quantity.

Use the bakery’s serving count where it publishes one. A diameter alone does not tell you how generously a deep-dish pie should be cut. The numbers below are planning arithmetic, not a promise about a particular product’s yield.

Budget for the whole dessert

Write down pie, tax, any delivery charge and extras before comparing totals. A larger pie is not automatically a better choice if it creates unwanted leftovers or needs a long pickup trip. Delivery can also change which option is economical.

If someone is bringing a pie to your house, send the guest count and tell them whether other desserts are covered. If you are the one bringing it, ask whether the host has fridge space before choosing a chilled dessert.

A simple slice planner

Choose your own portions per pie. Eight is an editable planning assumption, not a standard serving count for every bakery.

For example, 12 portions at eight per pie requires two pies, with four planned portions left.

This assumes one portion per person, equally sized pies and no other dessert. Use a lower yield if you want larger portions. It does not estimate dietary suitability, food storage or a bakery’s stock.

When the preorder window is gone

Buying a Thanksgiving pie at the last minute

A deadline passing does not mean every bakery is empty. It also does not mean a shop with an order button can still make the pie you want. Change the question from “Who sells pies?” to “Who can actually hand me one on my date?”

  1. Distinguish an order cutoff from a walk-in policy.Check whether the business publishes a separate arrangement for counter sales. The Flying Saucer and SusieCakes entries illustrate opposite policies. An unanswered phone call is not a reservation.
  2. Be flexible about the flavor, not the facts.If your preferred pie has sold out, ask which whole desserts are genuinely available. Get the price and format for the replacement. A frozen item, a box of minis and a ready-to-serve pie are not interchangeable on a tight schedule.
  3. Ask the pickup question before driving.Use the branch and holiday date from your confirmation. For a partner-café collection, the café is the collection site, not necessarily the place that baked your dessert. Leave enough time for the actual pickup window.
  4. Have one alternative that does not depend on another unconfirmed preorder.That might be a different dessert agreed with the host or a locally confirmed walk-in purchase. Do not promise a pie while still hoping an online basket will accept it.

No bakery in this guide is described as having guaranteed walk-in stock. We have not made test purchases or reserved inventory.

From the counter to the table

Collecting, carrying and serving your pie

Ask for the care instructions at pickup

Before leaving, check that the flavor and size match your receipt and ask when the pie should be eaten. Keep the label and instructions with the box, especially if another person will collect it or carry it to the gathering.

For a product sold frozen, follow its own baking directions. For a chilled dessert, plan transport and refrigerator space. A bakery’s instructions for one fruit pie should not be applied to every cream, custard or baklava dessert in this guide.

Make the trip part of the plan

Keep the box flat and supported, away from sliding bags and direct sun. If it needs refrigeration, use suitable cold transport and make it the last stop rather than leaving it in the car through a shopping trip.

The FDA advises refrigerating foods that need chilling within two hours, specifically including pumpkin pie, and keeping the refrigerator at or below 40°F. Follow product-specific labels and use-by directions as well. FDA holiday food guidance ↗

Dietary requests need a conversation. “Gluten-friendly” does not establish a dedicated gluten-free kitchen, and a flavor name does not establish that a dessert is nut-free, vegan or alcohol-free. Send the bakery the actual requirement and ask about fillings, crust, toppings and cross-contact before ordering. We have not assigned dietary-safe badges to these listings.
The details people check twice

Thanksgiving pie ordering questions

Can I pick up a Thanksgiving pie on November 26?

Pistaché advertises November 26 café pickup or DFW delivery, subject to the date and location available at checkout. Do not assume another bakery offers Thanksgiving Day collection simply because it sells holiday pies.

Which Houston pie shop does not take Thanksgiving-week preorders?

Flying Saucer’s 2026 notice says Thanksgiving-week sales are first come, first served, with no holds or reservations. Check its dated holiday schedule before visiting.

How much is a whole pumpkin pie in this guide?

Published examples include $25 at Ms. Myrtle’s, $29.95 at Village Baking Co. and $30 at Bakery Lorraine. Compare size, inclusions, collection dates and the final checkout amount rather than treating these as identical products.

Is The Blind Goat apple pie ready to eat at pickup?

No. Its seasonal page and linked form describe the apple pie as frozen with baking instructions. Confirm the exact size because the two sources show different diameters.

Can I walk into SusieCakes on November 25 and buy a Thanksgiving pie?

The retrieved PRC Dallas holiday menu says November 25 is for preordered pickups only and does not offer walk-ins that day. Confirm any exception directly with the selected store.

Does the filter show live availability?

No. It filters the published information recorded in this guide and compares stated deadlines with Central Time. It cannot see remaining pies, validate an accepted order or guarantee a collection slot.

Is every bakery in the guide inside the city listed?

No. Dallas / DFW includes nearby collection towns, which are named in the relevant entry. Bakery Lorraine also has multiple city choices. Use the selected location on the receipt, not the city heading alone.

Where can I order the rest of Thanksgiving dinner?

Use our Houston or Dallas Thanksgiving dinner-to-go guides for meals collected for home. Our statewide Thanksgiving restaurant guide covers dining-out options. Those are separate choices from ordering dessert alone.

How this shortlist was researched

Current sources, with the gaps left visible

We checked official bakery pages, branch ordering listings and holiday collection notices on November 19, 2026. This is desk research, not a claim that we visited, tasted each pie or called every bakery. Links beside the entries let you check the seller’s own information. We have not used review-site rankings to decide which pie tastes best.

Dates without a closing hour remain date-only deadlines. Prices unavailable in readable ordering text remain unquoted. Contradictions that affect a purchase—such as a pie’s diameter or a branch price—are disclosed rather than averaged or filled with estimates. A generic “sold out” label in a multi-variant store is not enough to establish every date and pickup branch is unavailable.

Deadline badges change with the date in America/Chicago. They report the stated ordering window, not live stock. A date-only cutoff gets a “confirm closing time” message on that day. Walk-in policies remain separate from preorders. After the holiday, this page labels the listings as the 2026 archive.

For the site’s wider sourcing approach, read how we check menus and offers. If a bakery changes its cutoff or collection instructions, send the relevant official update through our contact page.

Texas Restaurant Menus is an independent guide. Place and confirm orders directly with the bakery. Prices, product choices and remaining pickup capacity may change after the source check.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *